गलत इरादे सै दायर याचिका को भी नियम से निपटना है। किसी के इरादे गलत होना याचिका खारिज करने का आधार नहीं हो सकता ......
Supreme Court in catena of judgments and more particularly in the case of M. Narayandas Vs. State Of Karnataka 2004 Cr. L. J. 822 (SC) where it is ruled that The High Court cannot anticipate the result of the investigation or render a finding on question of malafides. Even if the Appellant had made the complaint on account of personal vendetta that by itself was not a ground to discard the complaint which had to be tested and weighed after the evidence was collectedas under;
“Even assuming that Dharam Pal has laid the complaint only on account of his personal animosity, that by itself, will not be a ground to discard the complaint containing serious allegations which have to be tested and weighed after the evidence is collected. …..
***For this reason the submission cannot be accepted. If as claimed there is no substance in the complaint the investigation will say so. At this stage there were only allegations and recriminations. The High Court could not have anticipated the result of the investigation or rendered a finding on question of malafides. Even if the Appellant had made the complaint on account of personal vendetta that by itself was not a ground to discard the complaint which had to be tested and weighed after the evidence was collected. ”
https://indiankanoon.org/doc/1073085/
Comments
Post a Comment